Here are the games per goal records – Qualification is current member of the squad with at least one goal, and former players with a minimum of 20 appearances and at least one goal.
| Jon Parry | 1.00 |
| Andy Cotton | 1.20 |
| Chris Dew | 1.27 |
| Rob Sterry | 1.31 |
| Alex Prentice | 1.78 |
| Scott Mathers | 2.04 |
| Stuart Nicholls | 2.20 |
| Chris Dundon | 2.30 |
| Jimmy Davis | 2.35 |
| Ian Lay | 2.50 |
| Karim Eljanfali | 2.50 |
| Andy Woodard | 3.00 |
| Paul Watt | 3.22 |
| Dave Soloway | 3.24 |
| Rob Cooke | 3.33 |
| Marc Duffy | 3.35 |
| Joel Moody | 3.35 |
| Russ Rapstone | 3.43 |
| Andy Sparrow | 3.50 |
| Richard Murphy | 3.51 |
| Richard Wenham | 3.54 |
| Lee Evans | 3.68 |
| Mark Brennan | 3.94 |
| Steve Eustice | 4.39 |
| Leigh Harrington | 4.43 |
| Paul Withey | 4.50 |
| Martin Pollard | 4.55 |
| Laurence Wells | 4.82 |
| Chris Keppel | 5.00 |
| Warren Flanagan | 5.31 |
| Aidy Spender | 5.45 |
| Wob Powell | 5.71 |
| Jon Richards | 6.00 |
| Chris Westcott | 6.15 |
| Martin Owen | 6.27 |
| Dean Driscoll | 6.38 |
| Paul Whittenbury | 6.54 |
| Simon Neill | 7.12 |
| Richard Walker | 7.50 |
| Matt Stamp | 7.67 |
| James Hannaford | 8.00 |
| Will Rowson | 8.00 |
| Tim Down | 8.17 |
| Stuart Holdham | 9.75 |
| Jamie Parkins | 9.93 |
| Panos Fellas | 10.71 |
| Andy Myall | 10.75 |
| Josh Freedman | 11.50 |
| Pete Fincham | 12.00 |
| Jon Neill | 13.00 |
| Paul Karlsen | 13.60 |
| Chris Davis | 14.00 |
| Matt Ainsley | 14.90 |
| Craig Urquhart | 16.00 |
| Matt Holliman | 16.00 |
| Simon Devon | 16.11 |
| Darren Sear | 17.29 |
| Mark Collins | 18.50 |
| James Collins | 19.50 |
| Miles Jacobson | 20.00 |
| Julian Carrera | 20.55 |
| Jeremy Hinds | 21.00 |
| Mat Ball | 21.00 |
| Ben Clarke | 23.00 |
| Richard Messenger | 24.00 |
| Alan Chatfield | 30.00 |
| Matt Wells | 34.00 |
| Andy Stocks | 34.33 |
| Paul Labbett | 38.00 |
| Tony Buckoke | 41.50 |
| Jerker Kjellander | 42.00 |
| Ian Grinstead | 43.00 |
| Dave Perahia | 62.00 |
| John Akers | 62.00 |
| David Morren | 65.00 |
| Dave Messenger | 67.00 |
| Phil McBride | 102.00 |
